Running a system
Use the exit you wrote. A streak is not a new size. · 13 min
Hook · The stop is touched
You wrote it before the entry. The feeling arrived after.
Price has reached the stop you wrote before you entered.
The size was calculated from that stop. A farther stop is a larger loss, decided while you are already in the trade. That is a different plan.
- Take the planned exit
- Move the stop farther away
Squeeze · The feeling is not a new rule
A system is the setup, the size, the exit, and the journal. Discipline means using the exit you wrote when you do not feel like it. Moving that stop farther makes the loss bigger than the size you chose, which breaks the division you already practiced. Adding to a loser to get back to even, with no rule that says to add, is a new trade wearing the old one’s name, and it adds heat you did not include. Skipping the next valid signal because the last one lost lets one outcome edit the rule. Raising size after a win streak treats a streak as a new edge. You already computed expectancy on a handful of R values and saw that a handful is not evidence. None of this is a comment on character. If the stop is not written, this lesson’s system is not on yet. A written daily loss limit is a rule, and stopping there is discipline. A mood is not a rule unless you wrote it down and are testing that version. The process column stays separate from the result column when you log the day.
Body · What did you write
The plan has no daily loss limit in these two.
A streak is not a new edge. The sample that justified the size did not update in three trades. Raising size mid-streak is how a normal loser becomes the one that matters.
- Keep the size in the plan
- Double it because you are hot
A written daily loss limit would be a rule, and stopping there would be discipline. This plan does not have one. Skipping a valid signal because of one loss is an edit. The irritation is real. It is not the rule.
- Skip it until the mood passes
- Take it if it meets the written rule
You planned a $2 stop on 100 shares, a $200 loss. You move the stop to $3 and keep the shares. Enter the new planned loss in dollars.
100 times $3 is $300. Moving the stop rewrote the risk in the middle of the trade. The recovery, if it comes, does not put the process column back.
Wicks · Adding, and a limit you did write
The second case flips, because the plan now has a daily stop.
The trade is down 1R. Nothing in the plan says to add. You buy more to get back to even. That is…
The size was the size. Adding increases the planned loss and the portfolio heat. If a written rule says when to add, following it is the system. This plan does not say it.
- The original system
- A new trade wearing the old one’s name, with more heat
- Required after a loss
The plan has a daily loss limit and you have hit it. The next signal is valid. Stopping for the day is…
The limit is ink. Stopping is discipline. The opposite case, skipping when you have not hit a limit you never wrote, is the edit. Read which plan you are in before you congratulate the feeling.
- You editing the rule out of mood
- You following the rule you wrote
- A way to double expectancy
Challenge · Fresh afternoons
A winner that broke the rule, then a stop moved one inch.
You moved the stop, the trade recovered, and you made +2R. Process is…
A broken rule that made money is still a broken process. One recovery does not rewrite the stop. The journal keeps both columns so the flattering result cannot eat the rule.
- Followed, because it worked
- Broken. The result can still be +2R
- Proof the farther stop is the new system
The stop you wrote is touched. Moving it farther…
Position size came from the distance to that stop. Moving it rewrites the risk in the middle of the trade. A win streak does not create a new stop rule.
- Protects the original plan
- Changes the loss to a size you did not choose
- Is required after three wins
Reveal · One afternoon, worked
Written plan: one setup, 1% planned loss, stop under the trigger low, no adding, no daily loss limit, journal both columns. The stop prints. You take the exit, −1R, process followed. The next bar is a fresh valid signal. You are irritated and you take it anyway, because the plan did not give you a daily stop. It loses too, another followed −1R. Heat for the day was 1% at a time, not 2% at once, because the first was closed. A friend doubled size after three earlier winners and then lost 2R on one trade. Their expectancy sample just got noisier, and their process column says broken if the written size was 1%. Nothing in the afternoon removed the chance of loss. The log is four cells: two results, two process marks.
In that afternoon, the second signal was taken while irritated. Process says…
The feeling is not the rule. The rule was silent on daily stops, and the signal met it. Write a daily stop if you want the other answer, and then follow that version.
- Broken, because of the feeling
- Followed, if the written rule had no daily stop and the signal was valid
- Unusable
Case · Case file: the stop you already wrote
The bars after the last one are hidden. Decide, then the path is shown.
Check · Fresh discipline
New afternoons.
The stop you wrote is touched. You move it farther and the trade later recovers. The process column records…
- Process followed, because it worked
- Process broken, result still green
- Nothing, because the recovery erased the edit
Answer
Process broken, result still green. A broken process and a green result. One recovery does not install a new stop rule.
The plan has no rule for adding to a loser. You buy more to get back to even. Heat…
- Increased. Adding was not the written size
- Fell, because the average price improved
- Stayed equal, because it is the same idea
Answer
Increased. Adding was not the written size. Went up. The new shares are a new decision wearing the old trade's name.
A written daily loss limit is hit. The next signal is valid. Stopping for the day is…
- Fear, and therefore a broken process
- A way to double the sample
- The rule, if that limit is really in the plan
Answer
The rule, if that limit is really in the plan. Following the limit you wrote. The opposite, skipping when you never wrote a limit, is the edit.
Three winners in a row. The written size is unchanged. Doubling the next trade makes the journal's size cell…
- Updated by the market
- Different from the size you wrote
- Required by the expectancy formula
Answer
Different from the size you wrote. Different from the plan. A streak of three is not a new sample and not a new edge.
Key terms
- System
- The setup, the size, the exit, and the journal. Discipline means using the exit you wrote when you do not feel like it. A followed loss is still the process. A broken rule that made money is still a broken process.