Portfolio risk and correlation
Add five planned losses. Correlation changes the odds, not the sum. · 13 min
Hook · Add, do not average
Five ideas can fall together. The sum does not care.
Five open ideas, each with a planned loss of 1%, all highly correlated. If every stop hits, the heat is about…
Add the planned losses. Correlation does not subtract them. It changes the chance they arrive together. A gap can make any single one larger than 1%.
- 1%, because they are really one idea
- 5%, and correlation changes how likely that is, not the arithmetic
- 0%, because correlation cancels losses
Squeeze · Ten stocks can be one bet
Correlation is a number from −1 to +1 describing how two return series have moved together in a past window. Positive means the same direction, zero means no straight-line relationship, negative means opposite. It changes. It is not a cause, and it is not a promise about next week. Heat, in this lesson, is the sum of the planned losses if every stop were hit. Five ideas at 1% each are about 5%. You already size each idea from its own stop. The portfolio step is to add those planned losses instead of feeling diversified because the tickers differ. An index ETF plus a stock that ETF already holds is overlap, not two unrelated ideas. You own the fund, not each company, and you can still be long the same economic bet twice. High correlation makes the same-day story more plausible. Low correlation does not subtract from the sum and does not make you safe. Gaps can make any one loss larger than its R. The common mistake is to hear 1% five times and remember 1%.
Body · Add the open risk
Each name is a 1% planned loss, and each one can fall with big tech. Turn all five on. The heat if every stop hits is the sum. Correlation does not shrink it.
Wicks · Different percents
Slide the count and the size. Then an ETF that already holds the stock.
Build a book of at least four ideas at 2% planned loss each. Read the heat.
Four times 2% is 8% if every stop hits. The slider does not apply a correlation discount. A 2% planned loss is already the gap-prone number from the size lesson, and four of them are four times that plan.
You are long SPY and also long a large stock that SPY already holds. The careful read is…
You own fund shares plus the stock. The fund already holds that company. Correlation between them is high because one contains the other. The planned losses still add. They are not a hedge of each other.
- Two unrelated ideas. Add nothing
- Overlap. The planned losses still add, and part of the bet is the same
- The stock cancels the ETF
Five ideas are open. Each planned loss is 0.5%. Enter the heat, in percent, if every stop hits on the same day and nothing gaps.
2.5. Correlation does not shrink the sum. A gap can make the day worse than 2.5. The ETF that already holds the same names would be the same bet again.
Challenge · Fresh books
A negative correlation that still does not subtract, then the definition.
Two ideas, 3% planned loss each, correlation −0.2 in the last window. If both stops hit, heat is…
Heat is the sum if every stop hits. Correlation changes how often you expect that day. It does not edit the addition. A mild negative number is not a hedge you can spend.
- About 0.6%, because the correlation shrinks the sum
- 6%. The negative number does not subtract planned losses
- 3%, the average
A correlation of +0.9 between two stocks means…
It is a past statistic about co-movement. It is not a mechanism and it is not a forecast. Both can still fall. That is the usual way a +0.9 pair hurts.
- They tended to move together in the window you measured, and the number can change
- One causes the other
- They cannot both fall
Reveal · Five names, worked
NVDA, AMD, AVGO, MSFT, and AAPL, each with a 1% planned loss, each able to fall with big tech. Turn them all on and the heat is 5% if every stop hits. A day that stops all five is more plausible when they have moved together than when they have not. Plausible is not the same as 5 becoming 1. Add a 1% short in something that has moved the other way and you still have 6% of planned loss if every stop hits, including the short’s stop. The short is not a minus sign in the heat sum. It is another planned loss. An overlap with QQQ, a fund that already holds these companies, would be the same bet a second time. The journal would show five −1R results on the bad day, or worse if any gap ran past the stop.
Those five 1% ideas, plus a 1% planned loss on QQQ, heat if every stop hits is about…
Add the planned losses. Overlap raises the chance they arrive together. It does not delete a line from the sum.
- 5%, because QQQ is the same idea and does not count
- 6%, and QQQ overlaps the stocks so the day is more plausible, not smaller
- 1%
Case · Case file: five names, one theme
The bars after the last one are hidden. Decide, then the path is shown.
Check · Fresh heat
New books.
Five open ideas, each a planned 1% loss, all able to fall with the same theme. If every stop hits, the heat is…
- About 5%, the sum of the planned losses
- About 1%, because each idea was 1%
- About 0%, because they are correlated
Answer
About 5%, the sum of the planned losses. About 5%, and a gap can make it more. Correlation does not subtract the planned losses.
A correlation near +0.9 between two stocks means, in this lesson…
- One is a hedge for the other
- They must move in opposite directions
- They have tended to move together
Answer
They have tended to move together. They have tended to move together. It is a description of the past, not a promise they will tomorrow.
You already hold an ETF that owns the same five names, and you also hold the names. The overlap is…
- A hedge, because the ETF is diversified
- The same exposure counted twice
- Zero heat, because the ETF is one ticker
Answer
The same exposure counted twice. The same bet twice. The ETF did not cancel the single-name heat.
You cut each planned loss from 1% to 0.5% and leave all five on. What changed?
- The sum of the planned losses
- The correlation, which falls when size falls
- Nothing, because five ideas are still five
Answer
The sum of the planned losses. The sum changed. Five halves are 2.5% if every stop hits. The count of ideas did not change.
Key terms
- Correlation
- A number from −1 to +1 describing how two return series have moved together in a past window. Positive means the same direction. It changes. It is not a cause, and it is not a promise about next week.
- Heat
- The sum of the planned losses if every stop were hit. Five ideas at 1% each are about 5%. Gaps can make any one of them larger. High correlation makes the same-day story more plausible. Low correlation does not subtract from the sum.