Short selling
Sell borrowed shares, and remember the loss sits above the price you sold. · 8 min
Hook · Where the loss is
The entry is a sale. Up is the wrong way.
You sell borrowed shares at 40. The price goes to 46. Before you cover, the loss per share is…
You sold at 40 and it would cost 46 to buy the shares back. That is $6 against you per share, before borrow fees. The dangerous direction is up, not down.
- $6
- $0, because you already sold
- Unlimited in the downward direction
Squeeze · Borrowed, sold, owed
A short sale borrows shares and sells them. Cash comes in. You owe the shares back. Covering buys them in the market and returns them. If the price falls, the buy-back is cheaper and the difference is the gain, before fees and before the cost of the borrow. If the price rises, the buy-back is more expensive and the difference is the loss. There is no ceiling on how high a price can go, so a short's loss is not capped the way a long stock's loss is capped by zero. The broker can force you to cover, and the lender can recall the shares. A short is not a put. A put you bought can expire worthless, and the most you lose is the premium. A short stock keeps the obligation until you cover or you are closed. From the order lesson, a buy-stop above the entry is one way to name where the idea is wrong. It can gap through, the same way any stop-market can.
Body · Mark the loss and the cover
Sold at 50. Do the subtraction in the right direction.
You are short from 50 and you buy the shares back at 58. Enter the loss per share, as a positive number.
58 minus 50 is 8. The loss is the cover minus the sale when the cover is higher. A long stock would have the signs the other way.
The idea is wrong above 53. Which order names that, from the order lesson?
You need to buy if price goes up. A buy stop waits for the trigger, then fires. A buy limit at 53 would try to buy cheaper, which is the wrong direction for an exit on a short. It can still gap through 53.
- A buy limit at 53, which waits to pay 53 or less
- A buy stop that fires if price trades up through 53
- A sell stop under 53
Wicks · Short stock is not a long put
The obligation is the difference.
You bought a put. The stock doubles. The most the put can cost you, if you hold it, is…
The put can go to zero. You are not forced to deliver shares. The short stock is the position that still owes shares after a rally.
- Unlimited, the same as a short stock
- The premium you paid
- Twice the stock price
The borrowed shares are recalled and your broker buys them back above your price. That is…
Recall ends the borrow. The cover happens at the market you are given, which can be worse than the stop you had written.
- A free exit
- A cover you did not time, at the available price
- Proof the short was a put
Challenge · Fresh prices
A winner, then the uncapped side.
Short from 30, cover at 23. Enter the gain per share, before fees and borrow cost.
30 minus 23 is 7. Borrow fees and a hard-to-borrow rate can eat that. The arithmetic of the prices is the easy part.
Why does this lesson say a short's loss is not capped by zero?
Zero is the floor for the stock, which helps a long. A short is hurt by the rise, and the rise has no matching floor.
- Because the stock can go below zero
- Because the stock can keep rising, and you owe shares
- Because brokers insure the upside
Reveal · One short, worked
Made-up: borrow and sell 100 shares at 40. The idea is wrong above 44, a buy-stop. Planned distance $4. If the planned dollar loss is $400, the count is 100 shares, which matches. Price prints 47 overnight. The stop fills at 47, a $7 loss, $700, not the $400 in the plan. That is the same gap lesson as a long stop, with the sign flipped. A long put struck at 40 would have had a different payoff and a premium paid up front. This position never bought that put.
The overnight fill lost more than the plan. The reason is…
A buy-stop-market becomes a market order. The gap skipped 44. The planned $4 was the picture, not a guaranteed fill.
- Shorts always fill worse
- The stop-market filled through 44 on the gap
- The borrow fee was $300
Check · Fresh shorts
New prices. Same direction.
Short from 22, the price is now 28, and you have not covered. The open loss per share is…
- $6
- $0, because the sale already happened
- $28, the whole price
Answer
$6. You would pay 28 for shares you sold at 22. That is $6 against you, before fees.
A buy stop above a short entry is there to…
- Add to the short if you were right
- Guarantee a fill at the stop price
- Name the price where the short idea is wrong
Answer
Name the price where the short idea is wrong. Buy the shares back if price trades up through the idea. It can gap.
A long put and a short stock both profit if the price falls. The loss if the price rises hard is…
- Identical, because both are bearish
- Capped on the put, open-ended on the short stock
- Capped on the short stock, because price cannot double
Answer
Capped on the put, open-ended on the short stock. Capped by the premium on the long put. Not capped the same way on the short stock.
The lender recalls the shares during a rally. Your broker covers you higher than the stop you wrote. That cover is…
- Part of being short borrowed shares
- Optional, because you can refuse
- The same event as a put expiring
Answer
Part of being short borrowed shares. A real exit you did not choose the moment for. Recall is part of the borrow.
Key terms
- Short sale
- You borrow shares and sell them, hoping to buy them back lower. You owe the shares. Buying them back is covering.
- Cover
- Buying back the shares you borrowed so the short is closed. The lender can also recall the borrow.